The renal microcirculation in chronic kidney disease: novel diagnostic methods and therapeutic perspectives

Abstract

Chronic kidney disease (CKD) affects 8–16% of the population worldwide and is characterized by fibrotic processes. Understanding the cellular and molecular mechanisms underpinning renal fibrosis is critical to the development of new therapeutics. Microvascular injury is considered an important contributor to renal progressive diseases. Vascular endothelium plays a significant role in responding to physical and chemical signals by generating factors that help maintain normal vascular tone, inhibit leukocyte adhesion and platelet aggregation, and suppress smooth muscle cell proliferation. Loss of the rich capillary network results in endothelial dysfunction, hypoxia, and inflammatory and oxidative effects and further leads to the imbalance of pro- and antiangiogenic factors, endothelial cell apoptosis and endothelial-mesenchymal transition. New techniques, including both invasive and noninvasive techniques, offer multiple methods to observe and monitor renal microcirculation and guide targeted therapeutic strategies. A better understanding of the role of endothelium in CKD will help in the development of effective interventions for renal microcirculation improvement. This review focuses on the role of microvascular injury in CKD, the methods to detect microvessels and the novel treatments to ameliorate renal fibrosis.

Introduction

The number of patients with chronic kidney disease (CKD) and consequently those progressing to end-stage renal disease (ESRD) is increasing, and the social, economic, and medical burden of CKD has received increased attention as a leading public health problem around the world [1]. The prevalence of CKD in China is as high as 10.8% according to a survey published in Lancet in 2012 [2]. Despite traditional drug and renal replacement therapies, the proportion of patients with CKD progressing to ESRD is still high, and the 5-year survival rate of dialysis patients is less than 50%. Therefore, protecting renal function is a leading public health goal, and a better understanding of the mechanisms underlying CKD is urgently needed.

Systemic microvascular rarefaction is one of the pathogenesis of the development of multiorgan damage in CKD patients, for example, in skeletal muscle, heart, and cerebrovascular disease. Flisinki et al. found that the microvascular density was significantly decreased in the locomotor muscle in rats with 5/6 nephrectomy comparing to the sham-operated controls, which may lead to uremic myopathy syndrome [3]. A greater decrease of microvascular rarefaction in the myocardium was also found in a few studies examining the heart in rodents with the CKD models, suggesting a systemic “toxic” effect of uremia on the endothelial cells [4,5,6]. In a study of Burns et al., 48% of CKD participants had mild or severe cognitive impairment, which may due to the cerebral vessel disease. This implicated that microvascular rarefaction in CKD is one of the pathogenesis of cognitive impairment [7]. Renal capillaries, which deliver oxygen and nutrients to the tubules, mediate vasoactivity, and maintain the local balance between pro- and antiangiogenic factors, are crucial for proper kidney function. Several recent studies have suggested renal capillary rarefaction and endothelial injury as significant pathophysiological processes promoting renal fibrosis [8,9,10,11,12]. Microvascular injury results in increased vasoconstriction, vascular permeability, activation of the complement system, inflammation, oxidative stress, and endothelial cell apoptosis/necrosis, and is thought to be closely linked to the progression of CKD to ESRD. In this review, we analyze the role of microvascular damage in CKD progression, summarize recent developments in experimental technology used to observe tissue microvasculature, and discuss the therapeutic issues related to targeting the restoration of renal capillaries.

Vascular endothelial function and dysfunction

Blood vasculature is important for the health of tissues as it facilitates the delivery of oxygen and nutrients. Endothelial cell injury is a major event in CKD that contributes to multiple macro- and microvascular damages. Healthy endothelium is considered a key contributor to the response to physical and chemical signals via maintaining barrier function, limiting platelet aggregation and adhesion, maintaining normal vascular tone and vascular homeostasis, regulating anti-inflammatory factors and coordinating immune response. Under physiological conditions, the intact vascular endothelium can effectively prevent pathogen invasion, at the same time, vascular endothelial cells synthesize and release tissue plasminogen activator (tPA), thrombomodulin (TM) and other anticoagulant substances, which make the blood in the blood vessel in a mild fibrinolytic state and maintain smooth blood circulation [13]. When the integrity of the vascular endothelium is destroyed and the collagen under the intima is exposed, platelet adhesion and aggregation will begin, and the aggregated platelets can release ADP, TXA2 and activated platelet activating factor (PAF), which can be triggered and exacerbated platelet aggregation. Endothelial cells and platelets work together to complete the process of hemostasis and blood vessel damage repair [14].

Another important function of endothelium is to regulate vascular tone, which results from the release of several vasoactive molecules that relax the vessel, such as nitric oxide (NO), or constrict the vessel, such as angiotensin-2 and endothelin (ET). NO is a physiological metabolite of L-arginine produced following the activation of endothelial NO synthase (eNOS) [15]. This eNOS-derived NO diffuses to the vascular smooth muscle cells and activates guanylate cyclase, which contributes to cGMP-mediated vasodilatation [16]. NO has diverse biological functions, including relaxing vascular smooth muscle and preventing its proliferation and inhibiting platelet aggregation and leukocyte activation. Therefore, a reduction in vasodilators may result in impaired endothelium-dependent vasorelaxation and subsequently lead to tissue ischemia and hypoxia. Angiotensin-2, the major activator in the renin–angiotensin system (RAS), has been shown to participate in endothelial dysfunction via its vasoconstrictive, proliferative and proinflammatory effects on vessels [17]. A study reported that activation of angiotensin-2 signaling triggers oxidative stress by inducing multiple downstream pathways, thereby resulting in growth arrest and apoptosis in endothelial cells. Blockage of angiotensin-2 signaling has been reported to protect the retinal vasculature by inhibiting endothelial cell apoptosis and improving blood flow [18]. Endothelin (ET) is mainly synthesized by endothelial cells and is a powerful vasoconstrictor. Serum ET-1 level (the main form of endothelin) plays an important role in maintaining basal vascular tone and cardiovascular system homeostasis [19]. Therefore, the imbalance of vasodilatative and vasoconstrictive molecules leads to impaired endothelial function.

The endothelium is also injured in response to the damage of vascular homeostasis, which is causing by an increase in antiangiogenic factors, such as angiopoietin-2 (Ang-2) [20], and thromboxane A2 [21], and a decrease in proangiogenic factors, such as Ang-1 [22, 23], vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF), and EGF [24]. An imbalance in proangiogenic and antiangiogenic factors results in functional defects and structural abnormalities in microvessels. Ang-1and Ang-2 are natural ligands of the Tie-2 receptor, which is expressed almost exclusively on endothelial cells and hemopoietic cells. Ang-1 could promote endothelial cell stability by binding and inducing tyrosine phosphorylation in Tie-2 [25, 26]. This reaction helps maintain a ‘quiescent’ phenotype in capillaries by inhibiting endothelial hyperpermeability, thereby preventing inflammatory cells from infiltrating renal interstitium and activating fibroblasts. The studies to date have demonstrated that Tie2 participates in angiogenesis, vessel remodeling and vessel maturation. Maisonpierre PC et al. showed that overexpression of Ang-2 could disrupt vessel formation in vivo, indicating that Ang-2 is a naturally competitive antagonist of Ang1 and the Tie2 receptor [27].

As an active part of the immune system, endothelial cells, in addition to ensuring the integrity of the structure and function of the blood vessel wall, can also express or up-regulate a variety of immune function-related molecules after activation, such as IL-1, IL-6, IFNβ, M2CSF, etc. [28]. Endothelial cells can not only serve as target cells for cytokines and inflammatory factors, but also secrete active mediators such as cytokines, and play an important role in the body's inflammatory and immune response processes.

Microvascular injury and kidney diseases

The kidney is a highly vascularized organ. Microvascular injury has been observed in different kidney diseases, which eventually progress to CKD. Rafael Kramann R et al. [29] directly showed decreased peritubular capillary (PTC) density and diameter of individual capillaries in long-term acute kidney injury (AKI) models by using a novel technique known as fluorescence microangiography (FMA), demonstrating a link between AKI leading to future CKD and loss of peritubular perfusion. Ehling J et al. [30] showed that mice with I/R-induced AKI exhibited significant capillary rarefaction at early time points after I/R injury by using microcomputed tomography (µCT) and 3D microarchitecture to analyze the renal vasculature. Although glomerular hypertrophy and hyperfiltration induced by neoangiogenesis of the microvessels were observed in early diabetes, the opposite was observed in advanced diabetic nephropathy, which is characterized by capillary rarefaction accompanied by local tissue hypoxia [31]. A study by Maric-Bilkan C et al. [32] showed that the density of microvessels with diameters under 100 μm was reduced by 34% after 4 weeks and by 75% after 12 weeks in the streptozotocin-induced diabetic models compared with the nondiabetic models by using micro-CT reconstruction of the renal microvascular architecture. Hypertension is second only to diabetes in leading to the development of CKD [33, 34], which is accompanied by functional and structural alterations in microvessels. Hao HF et al. [35] showed that renal arteries from spontaneous hypertensive rats (SHRs) exhibited less relaxation in response to acetylcholine, decreased phosphorylation of eNOS, and downregulation of NO production, suggesting that endothelial function is impaired in hypertension models. Recently, several studies have demonstrated that hyperuricemia is actively involved in the development of CKD. Kang DH [36] found that uric acid contributed to a phenotypic change in umbilical vein endothelial cells (HUVECs) to elongated fibroblast-like cells accompanied with endothelial cell apoptosis in vitro. Meanwhile, capillary rarefaction and increased fibrosis marked by α-SMA were detected in the animal model of hyperuricemia, demonstrating the progress of fibrosis in the kidney of hyperuricemic rats in vivo. According to the abovementioned studies, ischemia/reperfusion, diabetes, hypertension and hyperuricemia are some of the prevalent risk factors for endothelial dysfunction and injury, which lead to CKD. Moreover, microvascular injury is thought to be the common pathophysiological pathway in the progression to CKD.

The mechanism underlying the correlation between capillary rarefaction and CKD involves tissue hypoxia, recruitment of proinflammatory factors and reactive oxygen species (ROS), leukocyte adhesion and macrophage infiltration (Fig. 1).

Fig. 1

Mechanism underlying the correlation between capillary rarefaction and CKD involves the tissue hypoxia, recruitment of proinflammatory factors and reactive oxygen species (ROS), macrophages infiltration and pericyte detachment and migration. Loss of capillaries accompanied by hypoxia would induce an injury cascade with oxidative stress and inflammation. Proinflammatory cytokines induce not only increase expression of endothelial adhesion molecules but also cells present in the microenvironment, such as fibroblasts and myofibroblasts. Oxidative stress contributes to progression of kidney disease by upregulating production of ROS, which promote apoptosis and necrosis of endothelial cells. Oxidative stress and inflammation also promote endothelial-mesenchymal transition (EndMT) and epithelial-mesenchymal transition (EMT). Macrophages leak into the renal interstitium through injured endothelial cell–cell contacts and undergo macrophage-fibroblast transformation (MMT). The injured endothelial cells induced by stimulus deliver signals to pericytes, leading to the detachment of pericytes from the PTCs, migration into the interstitium, where they differentiate into myofibroblasts

Hypoxia

In 2002, Fine LG [37] proposed the breathing kidney, emphasizing the role of tubulointerstitial hypoxia accompanied with microvascular damage in progressive kidney disease. We are currently conducting a study that assesses renal hypoxia in patients with CKD using blood oxygenation level-dependent magnetic resonance imaging (BOLD-MRI), the only noninvasive method for evaluating tissue oxygen metabolism. We found that the blood perfusion of renal cortex in CKD patients was less than that in normal controls, indicating that hypoxia is closely related to renal injury. There are many mechanisms of hypoxia-induced renal interstitial fibrosis, most of which have been confirmed: (1) Hypoxia can stimulate the proliferation of fibroblasts, induce their transformation into myofibroblasts and increase extracellular matrix deposition [38, 39]. (2) Hypoxia can stimulate renal parenchyma cells to release protein factors related to renal fibrosis. These protein factors play a significant role in regulating tubulointerstitial fibrosis through paracrine and autocrine pathways [40]. (3) Hypoxia leads to vascular endothelial cell injury and microcirculation disorders, further decrease the availability of oxygen and nutrients for the tissue, and enhance tubular stress and endothelial cell injury, eventually forming a vicious cycle of hypoxia-induced microcirculation injury [41].

Inflammatory factors

Proinflammatory cytokines increase the expression of endothelial adhesion molecules, including ICAM-1, VCAM-1, and P-selectin in the PTCs [42]. This result enhances endothelium-leukocyte interactions, creating a vigorous proinflammatory state. Moreover, inflammatory activation results in apoptosis of endothelial cells and increase the exposure of endothelial adhesion molecules, which may also lead to impaired microcirculation, causing a positive feedback cycle in the inflammatory response. Some evidence showed that inhibition of the IL-1 receptor signaling molecule IRAK4 results in reduced kidney stromal cell proliferation and fibrosis, highlighting the role of proinflammatory cytokines in the profibrogenic molecular pathway [43].

Oxidative stress

Oxidative stress is a pathological state induced by an imbalance in the generation and clearance of ROS, which causes lipid peroxidation, increased hydrogen peroxide, and DNA and protein damage. Oxidative stress is elevated because of ischemia-induced hypoxia, which could increase the activity of NADPH oxidases and decrease the release of antioxidant proteins [44, 45]. ROS promote the apoptosis and necrosis of endothelial cells and endothelial cell-to-myofibroblast transition [46, 47] 48. Meanwhile, cell death and inflammation are signals for the recruitment and activation of myofibroblasts, which subsequently cause renal fibrosis [49].

The immune response

Both innate and adaptive immune responses contribute significantly to the progression of renal injury. Macrophages play an important role in host resistance to infection (innate immunity) and in removing apoptotic cells, cell fragments and foreign bodies. The accumulation of macrophages in the renal interstitium, caused by a damaged endothelial barrier and local proliferation of blood monocytes, is a common feature in most CKD cases. One of the mechanisms of macrophage-mediated fibrosis was elucidated by Neil C. Henderson et al., whom demonstrated that galectin-3 (a β-galactosidase-binding lectin) secreted by macrophages promotes renal fibrosis via a TGF-mediated pathway [50, 51]. Recently, in a study [52] of renal biopsy samples from patients with progressive CKD, coexpression of macrophage markers (F4/80 and CD68) and a fibrotic marker (α-SMA) in conjunction with the accumulation of collagen I were found in the renal interstitium, suggesting that macrophage-to-myofibroblast transition (MMT) may be another pathway that contributes to renal fibrosis in CKD.

Pericytes

A study conducted by Fligny C and colleagues [53] has identified pericyte detachment from capillaries as a critical step of capillary rarefaction [54]. Pericytes are mesenchymal cells located on the abluminal side of endothelial cells and contribute to the formation and stabilization of microvessels. The injured endothelial cells leads to the delivery of signals to pericytes, following which pericytes detach from the PTCs and migrate into the interstitial space, where they differentiate into myofibroblasts and subsequently contribute directly to pathological matrix deposition [55]. The consequence of this action for microvessels is instability, increased leakage and a damaged basement membrane. Molecular and cellular mechanisms by which pericytes regulate microvascular stability were recently reported [56], identifying TIMP3 as a pericyte factor that improves vascular stability by detecting the loss of TIMP3 during pericyte transition to myofibroblasts. Moreover, TIMP3 has been demonstrated to prevent the activity of some matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs) and a disintegrin and metalloproteinase with thrombospondin motifs-1 (ADAMTS1) and suppress the activation of the endothelial receptor VEGFR2. TIMP3-deficient mice showed more-severe endothelial abnormalities and interstitial fibrosis due to an increase in migration, proliferation and expression of a-SMA and ADAMTS1, which could accelerate capillary tube regression. In a recent study, Kramann R et al. [57] verified their hypothesis that pericyte loss led to tubular injury and PTC rarefaction. Gli1 + pericytes represent a small subfraction of interstitial kidney cells, but a primary source of renal myofibroblasts. After kidney injury, Gli1 + cells detach from microvessel, and ablation of Gli1 + cells induces tissue hypoxia, an inflammatory response, and subsequent sustained capillary rarefaction. Therefore, pericytes might also be a key factor that affects the development of renal fibrosis.

Methods for assessing microvessels in CKD

Progressive kidney diseases are related to endothelial injury and capillary rarefaction. Therefore, to better understand these pathophysiological processes, tools enabling the quantitative and noninvasive monitoring of vascular changes are required. Microvascular density is usually measured by immunostaining (endothelial cell antigens, such as CD31), estimating the surface area of endothelial cells or counting the number of genetically labeled endothelium (such as Tie 2). However, these methods may lead to errors. Several new technologies have been used to observe tissue microvasculature in recent years (Table 1).

Synchrotron radiation (SR) for visualizing structures within nephrons

Synchrotron radiation (SR) could help to achieve greater spatial resolution compared with conventional X-ray. Several studies have reported the successful application of SR in angiography. Sonobe T et al. indicated that SR is an effective tool for microangiography of the pulmonary microcirculation (diameters < 100 micron) in the rat [58, 59]. SR contrast angiography has been applied on coronary arteries as small as 100 micron in diameter in a beating heart and 50 micron in an arrested heart [60]. A change in renal microcirculation is closely associated with renal failure. Therefore, SR could be used for investigating structures within nephrons. The SR derived X- rays transmitted through the subjects were recorded by a CCD camera. And the X-rays are converted to visible light on a fluorescent screen. A study of Miya K group showed that the SR renal microangiography (SRRM) was applied to visualize proximal tubules, glomeruli, and renal arterioles, and the minimum diameter of the observed arteriole was 18 μm [61]. A limitation of this method is that all images of nephrons are projected, which do not fully reflect the three-dimensional structures within kidneys.

Microcomputed tomography (μCT) for anatomical and functional imaging of vascular alterations

μCT for anatomical and functional imaging of microvascular changes could clearly show the branching, size and tortuosity of blood vessels. μCT has already been employed in cancer research, which is characterized by different degrees of angiogenesis. The combination of functional in vivo and anatomical ex vivo X-ray μCT enables a highly precise quantification of relative blood volume and highly detailed analysis of the three-dimensional micromorphology of tumor vessels [62]. Ehling J et al. indicated that the μCT method could accurately reflect hepatic blood vessel alterations in liver fibrosis and become a promising tool for estimating angiogenesis and the effects of antiangiogenic therapy [63]. In renal artery stenosis (RAS) pigs, we have found decreased density of small-size cortical microvessels (< 200 mm) and atherosclerosis-aggravated loss of renal cortical microvessels by using μCT, both of which lead to accelerated renal dysfunction [64]. A research team from Germany used μCT to observe macro-to-microvascular changes in three murine models with different mechanisms of progressive renal disease: the unilateral ureteral obstruction (UUO) model, ischemia–reperfusion (I/R) injury model, and progressive glomerulonephritis model (Alport mice), demonstrating the close correlation between PTC rarefaction and kidney injury. Mice were imaged before and immediately after intravenous injection of 100 ml eXIATM160XL, which is an iodine-based contrast agent optimized for in vivo μCT-based blood pool imaging,This method provide a noninvasive visualization of renal vessels with a spatial resolution of 35 mm voxel side length [30]. However, there are some limitations to this method, including X-ray exposure and the need for iodine-based contrast agents [65].

FMA method for assessing the microvascular architecture of the kidney

Recently, Advani A and colleagues [66] reported the use of fluorescence microangiography (FMA) by renal artery injection in 5/6 nephrectomy mice. The FMA method allowed the three-dimensional reconstruction of renal microvasculature and circumvents and identified a decrease in both glomerular and PTC density in subtotally nephrectomized rats. FMA uses low-melting-point agarose with fluorescent polystyrene microspheres, which could perfuse the microvasculature and provide a microangiogram via confocal microscopy. The FMA method provides an optimal structure of the renal microvessels and avoids limitations of endothelial antigens, which may be coexpressed by the lymphatic vasculature. Moreover, a team from Harvard Medical School improved this technique by intracardiac injection, allowing a highly distinct visualization of vascular perfusion in the kidney, heart and liver. Additionally, the team created a MATLAB-based script that allows the precise analysis of totally perfused cortices, capillary number and even the perimeter and area of the individual capillary cross-section. These researchers found that the loss of peritubular perfusion and capillary density in the AKI model was closely correlated with the severity of renal injury and further leads to renal interstitial fibrosis [29]. In our recently study, we applied FMA method to evaluate the renal microvasculature and found that the capillary number and total perfused area were reduced in the UUO 7d group compared with the sham group. Additionally, in order to mark the outline of PTCs, CD31, an endothelial cell antigens expressed on endothelial cell surface was utilized, and showed that capillaries surrounded by CD31 + endothelial cells in the UUO group appeared a decreased luminal FMA signal, indicating a lack of perfusion of these capillary vessels [67] (Fig. 2a).

Fig. 2

a The fluorescent microangiography (FMA) method is based on low-melting-point agarose with fluorescent polystyrene microspheres which could perfuse the microvasculature and identified a decrease in both glomerular and PTC density in the kidneys of UUO model. Immunostaining surrounding with CD31 (expressed on the surface of endothelial cells) demonstrates capillary rarefaction in response to the obstructed kidney. b Renal R2* images in the CKD patient: Uneven blue in the cortex indicates decreased cortical oxygenation. The large green, yellow and red areas in the medulla indicate decreased medullary oxygenation

Blood Oxygen Level- dependent Magnetic Resonance Imaging (BOLD-MRI) for accessing tissue oxygen metabolism

BOLD-MRI, which is based on paramagnetic properties of deoxyhemoglobin, could evaluate the degree of tissue hypoxia by measuring the deoxyhemoglobin level. BOLD-MRI is also the only noninvasive, safe and reliable method to access tissue oxygen metabolism [68]. BOLD-MRI is primarily used in brain functional imaging. With advances in scanning technology, BOLD-MRI has been applied more widely in kidney diseases, including I/R renal injury [69], diabetic nephrology [70], contrast nephropathies [71] and renal allograft rejection [72]. Renal diseases are often accompanied by changes in microvascular and renal perfusion, which further induce hypoxia in tissue. Therefore, changes in the level of oxygenation in the kidney can often reflect abnormal changes in the early stage of the disease and indirectly evaluate the microcirculation of the tissues. A research team from the Mayo Clinic explored the relationship between renal blood oxygen level and renal blood perfusion in patients with renal vascular diseases before and after the use of diuretics by using BOLD-MRI. This team found that the decrease in blood flow and GFR were closely related to the fractional hypoxia of kidney tissue and that a diuretic could improve renal hypoxia [73]. In a study from our group, we used regional and whole-kidney ROI selection methods combined with the 3.0-T MRI creatively to evaluate the renal oxygenation in CKD patients. This system automatically generated an R2* pseudocolor map showing a gradual transition from blue (represents high renal tissue oxygenation) to green, yellow and red (represents significant hypoxia), indicating a gradual increase in renal hypoxia. The results showed decreased cortical and medullary oxygenation compared with the healthy people [74] (Fig. 2b). In addition, BOLD-MRI avoids the use of exogenous contrast agent, which is a great advantage for clinical application.

Electron microscopy for visualizing subtle ultrastructure of the endothelium

Normal peritubular capillary endothelial cells are thin or flat with regular contours. The cell soma of endothelial cells is perforated by fenestrations, which make the cytoplasm travel in small segments. Electron microscopy is the only method to visualize subtle ultrastructure, indicating that the very early changes of endothelial cells could be detected. Babickova J et al. [9] have studied the ultrastructural alterations of the microvasculature in 3 murine models of different kidney disease. Compared with the kidneys of control group, decreased numbers of fenestrations, the widening of the subendothelial space and increased numbers of endothelial vacuoles and caveolae were detected by Electron microscopy in fibrotic kidneys. These findings allow us to visualize the damage of endothelial cells of PTCs in progressive kidney disease and is in line with recent data showing the role of microvascular endothelium in renal intestitial fibrosis [75]. However, the limitation to this method is the potential sampling error, because only a very small amount of tissue is analyzed.

Intravital multiphoton microscopy (MPM) for the single-cell–level investigation

MPM is a powerful technique to study alterations in tissue morphology and function simultaneously in the living animal, which perform long-term cell fate tracing of the same renal cells by following ex vivo histology [76]. Completely noninvasive and high-quality renal imaging can be achieved through an abdominal imaging window (AIW), which consists of coverslipped titanium ring, adhering to the kidney. This enables researchers to obtain structural and functional data of individual nephron in the same region within a certain period of time, avoids the problem of heterogeneity of renal tissue, and establishes the dynamics and patterns of individual cell’ movement and migration over time. Schiessl IM's group [77] have successfully use this method to track the migration and differentiation of individual renal progenitor cell in homozygous Ren1d-Confetti reporter mice. Schiessl IM et al. [78] have investigated tubular cells migrate and proliferate to the location of ablated tubular cells and reconstitute the functional integrity of the tubule by using MPM with subsequent ex vivo histology. Therefore, we believe that this new technique is hopeful to be applied to the dynamic observation of renal endothelial cells and renal interstitial cells, and cell-to-cell communication with functional alterations in vivo.

Therapeutic strategies targeting injured microvessels

CKD is characterized by renal fibrosis, with excessive accumulation of extracellular matrix leading to progressive renal failure. Mounting evidence has demonstrated the significant role of microvasculature injury in the development of interstitial fibrosis and CKD progression. Therefore, restoration of renal microcirculation is a rapidly expanding area of research and a promising therapy for the prevention of kidney fibrosis. Unfortunately, despite current treatments, the majority of patients still experience progressive renal failure and develop ESRD. To solve these conventional therapeutic limitations, new and affordable therapies are urgently needed.

Growth factors and cytokines

Several growth factors and cytokines have been reported to ameliorate renal fibrosis in experimental models of CKD (Table 2).

Table 1 Methods of accessing microvessels in CKD

Table 2 Growth factors and cytokines for improving renal microcirculation

VEGF has shown promise in improving renal function in various models of renal disease. Tissue hypoxia induced by chronic ischemia not only leads to significant microvascular injury but also an impaired angiogenic response that results in decreased expression of VEGF and altered downstream signaling pathways[67, 79, 80]. Based on these findings, VEGF is regarded as one of the promising therapeutic growth factors for microcirculation improvement and is well known as the most potent inducer of angiogenesis and an endogenous regulator of endothelial integrity. Chade AR et al. demonstrated that intrarenal VEGF therapy significantly reduced microcirculation injury and restored renal function in a swine model of RAS through the induction of proliferation, endothelial tube formation, and migration of endothelial cells. However, as VEGF is limited by its short t1/2 and its susceptibility to degradation, a biopolymer-stabilized elastin-like polypeptide (ELP)-VEGF fusion protein was generated to improve the bioavailability of VEGF. The study indicated that renoprotective effects after ELP-VEGF therapy was largely driven by modulation of renal macrophages toward the anti-inflammatory M2 phenotype, restoring VEGF signaling and sustaining improvement of renal function and microvascular integrity in CKD [81].

A group of Xu J demonstrated that GLP-1R agonist have a protective effect against renal interstitial fibrosis induced by renal microcirculation injury. Activating GLP-1R resulted in positive effect via antiapoptotic effect, inhibiting the phenotypic conversion of renal microvascular vascular smooth muscle cells, and inhibiting endothelial-to-mesenchymal transition (EndMT) through increasing BMPR2 and decreasing TGF- β1 [82].

Angiopoietin-1 (Ang-1), a vascular growth factor secreted by renal proximal tubular cells and podocytes, has endothelial network formation and potent EC sprouting and migration capacity. Ang-1-deficient mice have been reported to exhibit severe organ damage, and fibrosis was promoted via the regulation of vascular density. Moreover, Singh S showed a potential therapeutic effect of Ang-1 by activating Tie2 to inhibit TNFα-induced leukocyte capillary transmigration and ultimately repairing microvasculature damage [83].

Insulin-like growth factor-1 receptor (IGF-1R), a member of the tyrosine kinase receptor superfamily, is a transmembrane receptor. IGF-I and IGF-II receptors are abundantly expressed on endothelial cells, demonstrating that these growth factors play a physiological role in microvessels [84]. IGF-1R contributes to the regulation of cellular proliferation, differentiation, and survival. To demonstrate the critical role of IGF-1R in maintaining endothelial function, Liang M et al. established IGF-1R KO mice and detected increased interstitial fibrosis and enhanced extracellular matrix (ECM) deposition. Conversely, inflammation and renal fibroblast induced by UUO were mitigated after IGF-1R overexpression by reducing vascular hyperpermeability [85].

Netrin-1 is a laminin-related secreted protein that could play a critical role in promoting vascular endothelial cell migration and angiogenesis. Several studies have reported the protective effect of netrin-1 on kidney diseases, including I/R renal injury and diabetic nephropathy [86]. Therefore, Bai J et al. explored the potential therapeutic effect of netrin-1 on CKD. Animal experiments were performed to demonstrate that netrin-1 could alleviate the progression of renal failure and attenuate interstitial fibrosis by suppressing EndMT in 5/6 nephrectomy rats via blockade of the TGF-β/Snail/α-SMA signaling pathway [87].

Cell therapy

Cell-based therapy is not only the most advanced regenerative therapeutic strategy to date but one that has shown great promise for the treatment of CKD [88]. The most widely used cell is the stem cell, given its ability to be used in animal models of kidney diseases [89, 90]. By targeting the underlying mechanism of the renal diseases, stem cell-based therapy restores the structure and functionality of damaged tissues by stimulating the endogenous regenerative capacity [91]. There are different types of stem cells available for regenerative therapy (Table 3). Embryonic stem cells (ESCs) and human induced pluripotent stem cells (hiPSCs) are those with the most differentiation potency. However, these cells also seem to have the greatest tumorigenesis property. Van den Berg et al. [92] demonstrated that hiPSC-derived kidney organoids develop host-derived vascularization in vivo and contribute to the formation of a glomerular basement membrane and fenestrated endothelial cells as detected by ultrastructural evaluation. Musah et al. [93] showed that hiPSCs had a remarkable capacity to self-renew indefinitely and differentiate into endothelial cells by coculture with human kidney glomerular endothelium. Despite their potent differentiation capacity, the widespread use of ESCs and hiPSCs are limited by ethical issues and high tumorigenicity [94].

Table 3 Cell-based therapy for improving renal microcirculation

Endothelial progenitor cells (EPCs), which are derived from the bone marrow, play a critical role in repairing injured microvessels and promoting angiogenesis. Chen et al. reported that CKD patients showed lower EPC numbers in circulation compared with heathy controls, which is associated with cell apoptosis resulting from increased oxidative stress and correlated to defective neovascularization and endothelial dysfunction [95]. Based on their capacity to regenerate endothelium, EPCs are considered a promising therapeutic agent for CKD. Intrarenal infusion of autologous EPCs has been reported to improve renal microcirculation in chronic experimental renovascular disease. Microvascular density and vascular volume were increased after the administration of EPCs, as detected directly by μCT. EPCs could not only generate new vessels but also promote the stabilization and maturation of the new vessels, resulting in renal protection [96]. In our previous study, bone marrow-derived EPC transplantation stimulated the release of angiogenic cytokines and increased PTC density. Therefore, blood supply to renal tubules and oxygen delivery were improved, leading to further alleviation of renal interstitial fibrosis in obstructive nephropathy in mice [97]. The mechanism by which EPCs preserve capillaries and promote angiogenesis involves homing to the injured kidney and paracrine secretion of growth factors [4, 98].

Mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) are the most widely used cells in regenerative medicine therapy of kidney diseases [99]. To date, approximately 1068 active clinical trials investigating the potential of MSCs are listed in the US National Library of Medicine (http://clinicaltrials.gov, Mar 2020). These clinical trials span a broad range of applications, such as in the treatment of tumors, diabetes mellitus, sexual dysfunction, hematological diseases, ischemic injuries, and immune disorders (including autoimmune urticarial, lupus, systemic scleroderma, Crohn’s disease, and graft-versus-host disease) and in soft tissue regeneration. Among these trials, 33 are investigating MSC targeting in kidney diseases. A research team from the Mayo Clinic has completed a clinical trial on 14 atherosclerotic renovascular disease (RVD) patients and demonstrated the safety and efficacy of intraarterial injection of autologous adipose-derived MSCs [100]. MSC infusion could alleviate renal tissue hypoxia and increase the cortical blood supply to ameliorate the progression of renal failure. Several studies have recently shown that MSCs play an important role in preserving renal microvessels and relieving kidney injury in a variety of kidney disease models (Table 3). Furthermore, MSCs can be obtained from a variety of tissues, including adipose tissue [101, 102], bone marrow [103,104,105] and amniotic fluid [106, 107], and have been reported to have antioxidative, anti-inflammation, proangiogenic, and immunomodulatory function in numerous experimental studies. More specifically, the functions (including differentiation, immunosuppression, and release of cytokines and factors) of MSCs isolated from adipose tissue of renal disease patients were not affected by exposure to uremic conditions. These results indicate the feasibility of developing therapies with autologous MSCs for renal failure patients [108].

Kidney‐specific intervention by targeting genes

Several studies have demonstrated that some genes play a significant role in renal injury by detecting their high expression in different animal models (Table 4). Therefore, inhibition of specific genes is considered a potential therapeutic approach. Deng et al. [109] found that protein phosphatase 2A (PP2A) is significantly activated by TGF-β1 stimulation, but endothelial integrity and function are restored after inhibiting PP2A activation, thereby preventing the progression of endothelial cell differentiation into scar-forming myofibroblasts. A study from Stuart W S showed that the genetic loss of CD248, a type I transmembrane glyco-protein that is expressed by stromal fibroblasts and myofibroblasts, could protect against myofibroblast accumulation through alleviating microvascular rarefaction and modulation of pericyte and stromal cell function [110]. There is increasing evidence that EGFR activation plays an important role in the initiation and progression of renal disease. EGF deletion has been reported to have a protective role in acute kidney injury [111], glomerular injury [112] and diabetic nephropathy [113]. Furthermore, Zeng et al. demonstrated that endothelial deletion of heparin-binding EGF-like factor (HB-EGF) attenuated endothelial cell apoptosis, resulting in the protection of glomerular capillary integrity and, consequently, the alleviation of renal fibrosis [114]. Our previous study also found that a specific gene, thrombospondin-1 (TSP-1), was highly expressed in the interstitium of both experimental [115] and human [116] interstitial fibrosis and that suppression of TSP-1 increased VEGF levels and PTC density. These results suggested that TSP-1 gene silencing prevented renal fibrosis and may become a new potential therapy for CKD. Recent evidence indicates that long non-coding RNA (lncRNA) is rapidly emerging as a promising drug targeting angiogenesis. Knock- down of lncRNA MALAT1 is reported to inhibit high glucose induced-fibrosis in the diabetic nephropathy model, which may due to the mechanism of supressing endothelial to mesenchymal transition via targeting miR-145/ZEB2 axis. These results provide a novel potential target for renal disease in the future [117]. Although many promising therapeutic strategies aiming to silence endothelial genes and restore renal microcirculation have been confirmed to be effective in animal models, to date, there is still a lack of evidence from clinical trials.

Table 4 Kidney-specific intervention targeting genes for improving renal microcirculation

Conclusion

The endothelium is considered a key contributor to the maintenance of normal vascular homeostasis, and injured endothelial cells lead to progressive fibrosis and loss of renal function. A number of cellular mechanisms are involved, including tissue hypoxia, inflammatory cell infiltration, oxidative stress, the immune response, pericyte detachment and EndoMT. Techniques for assessing renal microcirculation will help acquire a better understanding of the role of capillary rarefaction in CKD and direct therapeutic strategies to restoring capillaries. Based on the close relationship between microvascular damage and kidney diseases, novel therapeutic options targeted toward endothelium have become promising therapies and are thus expected to become effective clinical treatments for patients with CKD. Science and technology development fund of Affiliated Hospital of Xuzhou Medical University (XYFC2020001; XYFY2020038).