Bioinformatic analysis reveals the expression of unique transcriptomic signatures in Zika virus infected human neural stem cells

Background The single-stranded RNA Flavivirus, Zika virus (ZIKV), has recently re-emerged and spread rapidly across the western hemisphere’s equatorial countries, primarily through Aedes mosquito transmission. While symptoms in adult infections appear to be self-limiting and mild, severe birth defects, such as microcephaly, have been linked to infection during early pregnancy. Recently, Tang et al. (Cell Stem Cell 2016, doi: 10.1016/j.stem.2016.02.016) demonstrated that ZIKV efficiently infects induced pluripotent stem cell (iPSC) derived human neural progenitor cells (hNPCs), resulting in cell cycle abnormalities and apoptosis. Consequently, hNPCs are a suggested ZIKV target. Methods We analyzed the transcriptomic sequencing (RNA-seq) data (GEO: GSE78711) of ZIKV (Strain: MR766) infected hNPCs. For comparison to the ZIKV-infected hNPCs, the expression data from hNPCs infected with human cytomegalovirus (CMV) (Strain: AD169) was used (GEO: GSE35295). Utilizing a combination of Gene Ontology, database of human diseases, and pathway analysis, we generated a putative systemic model of infection supported by known molecular pathways of other highly related viruses. Results We analyzed RNA-sequencing data for transcript expression alterations in ZIKV-infected hNPCs, and then compared them to expression patterns of iPSC-derived hNPCs infected with CMV, a virus that can also induce severe congenital neurological defects in developing fetuses. We demonstrate for the first time that many of cellular pathways correlate with clinical pathologies following ZIKV infection such as microcephaly, congenital nervous system disorders and epilepsy. Furthermore, ZIKV activates several inflammatory signals within infected hNPCs that are implicated in innate and acquired immune responses, while CMV-infected hNPCs showed limited representation of these pathways. Moreover, several genes related to pathogen responses are significantly upregulated upon ZIKV infection, but not perturbed in CMV-infected hNPCs. Conclusion The presented study is the first to report enrichment of numerous pro-inflammatory pathways in ZIKV-infected hNPCs, indicating that hNPCs are capable of signaling through canonical pro-inflammatory pathways following viral infection. By defining gene expression profiles, new factors in the pathogenesis of ZIKV were identified which could help develop new therapeutic strategies.

However, ZIKV infection is also believed to be related to the concurrent increase in adult Guillain-Barré syndrome (GBS) cases [4]. This is supported by a case controlled prospective study of the French Polynesian outbreak, where ZIKV was linked with increased incidence of GBS [3]. Aside from its effects in adults, ZIKV infection of pregnant women can result in birth defects ranging from low birth weight to craniofacial and eye abnormalities [6], as well as microcephaly [7,8]. The detection of ZIKV in fetal brain tissues indicates that ZIKV can also cross the placental barrier [9]. Consequently, curbing the current ZIKV epidemic has become a top priority for a number of international health initiatives.
Prompt laboratory-based efforts by Tang et al. provided RNA-seq data (GEO: GSE78711) from ZIKV-infected human neural progenitor cells (hNPCs). They found that when compared to neurons and embryonic stem cells, ZIKV infects hNPCs with high efficiency, and that infection results in abnormal cell cycle dynamics and apoptosis [9]. For the current study, we analyzed this dataset using bioinformatic methods to uncover links between neuroinflammatory pathways and ZIKV infection of hNPCs, as well as its correlation with clinical neurological symptoms. Since congenital CMV infection is also associated with higher incidence of neurological birth defects [10], a CMV-infected hNPC dataset (GEO: GSE19345) was used for comparison [11]. We demonstrate for the first time that ZIKV activates several inflammatory signals within infected hNPCs that are implicated in both innate and acquired immune responses. Moreover, several genes related to pathogen responses are significantly up-regulated in response to ZIKV infection, but not perturbed in CMV-infected hNPCs. Our approach offers novel insight into the potential mechanisms underlying ZIKV infection and provides useful directions for future clinical research.

Comprehensive gene set gene ontology analysis
Comparison of the mock-infected samples to the ZIKVinfected samples using a modified t-test yields a total of 3443 genes up-regulated and 3421 down-regulated. The top 30 highest absolute fold-change (FC) genes are reported in Tables 1 and 2 along with their associated Entrez IDs and p-values. Gene Ontology (GO) term analysis showed that the up-regulated gene set was exclusively enriched in processes related to nucleic acid metabolism regulation (Fig. 1a). Since replication of the viral genome requires reallocation of host nucleotides [12], this finding was unsurprising. Also, the down-regulated gene set was enriched for DNA metabolism processes, although with emphasis on cell cycle regulation. These findings were consistent with evidence showing ZIKV infection results in the down-regulation of cell cycle genes, impaired cell cycle progression through G 1 [9], and decreased proliferation [13] in vitro. Of the ZIKV down-regulated genes, the biological process most enriched proved to be chromosome segregation. This finding provides an interesting link to known causes of hereditary microcephaly, as abnormal brain development and reduced volume often are the result of dysregulation of chromosome segregation [14,15].
By also assessing cellular compartment sub-ontology, we elucidated the cellular location of the infection induced gene expression alterations (Fig. 1b). Genes down-regulated by ZIKV were highly enriched in centromeric and nuclear sites, the extracellular matrix, and mitochondria. Furthermore, down-regulated genes were associated with exosomes, suggesting that the infection can influence exosome biology. Up-regulated genes were enriched specifically in the Golgi complex, the cytoplasm, and the monocytic leukemia zinc-finger protein/related factor (MOZ/MORF) histone acetyltransferase complex, which serves as a regulator of neural and hematopoietic stem-cell identity [16].

ZIKV DEGs represented in canonical human neurological diseases
To investigate whether ZIKV induced differentially expressed genes (DEGs) are related to the observed clinical phenotypes, comparisons were made between significant ZIKV DEGs and those related to the pathogenesis of human neurological diseases ( Fig. 2) (Table 3). Considering that hNPCs were used for the RNA-seq study, our inquiry was limited to diseases of the nervous system. Using the MalaCards [17] integrated searchable database of human diseases, we selected six conditions for comparison. Each condition is a parent disease relating subcategories of more specific diseases. For each condition, the number of ZIKV DEGs present in the MalaCards reference list is reported as the represented percentage. The number of total genes in each MalaCards reference list is plotted along the second y-axis (scatterplot). The condition with the most representation proved to be microcephaly, with 70 % of the 30 reference list genes present in the ZIKV DEGs. Since, epilepsy is a common microcephaly co-morbidly [18], it was unsurprising to discover there was 43 % representation of related genes. The more general group of congenital nervous system disorders also displayed a similarly high representation of ZIKV DEGs at 60 % of the total reference list. Since, there has also been an increase in reported cases of adult GBS in ZIKV affected areas [2,3], we investigated encephalitis, demyelinating diseases, and GBS specifically. While representation of ZIKV DEGs in these disease classifications were present, it was significantly less than congenital central nervous system (CNS) diseases.

GO network mapping reveals connections between hNPC ZIKV infection and the immune system
A wide variety of cell types outside the traditional immune system can respond to the threat of pathogens [19]. Thus, investigations were conducted to determine if infected hNPCs presented a pattern of gene expression consistent with a defense response. To visualize the intracellular networks regulating expression changes, a GO network map was generated (Fig. 3). All significant ZIKV DEGs greater than 0.5 absolute log fold-change were loaded into Cytoscape [20], and gene ontology clustering was performed with the ClueGO plugin [21]. The human genome was used as the background with GO biological process and immune system terms queried for enrichment. GO terms for biological processes are denoted with a circle, while GO immune system terms are denoted with a triangle. As expected, nucleic acid metabolic processes were heavily enriched and connected, representing the majority of the network and indicating that they are not a directly connected to the immune system terms. Of the eight main networks identified, four were associated with immune system response. The identified networks were immune response, cytokine production, leukocyte activation, and defense response to other organisms. Additionally, cell cycle, negative regulation of macromolecule biosynthetic process, and cellular macromolecule metabolic process terms were represented.
To explore if the alterations in immune related gene expression seen in ZIKV-infected hNPCs was consistent with other viral infections, we compared the ZIKV expression profile to that of CMV-infected human induced pluripotent stem (iPS) derived NPCs. This gene set provided well matched data for comparison, since the hNPCs in both studies were derived from iPS cells and implement Illumina transcript analysis [9,23]. Additionally, hNPCs have demonstrated permissiveness to both viruses and infection in early fetal development with either virus has been linked to similar congenital neurological defects [9,11,23,24]. The significant CMV related DEGs were analyzed in the same manner as the ZIKV related DEGs, such that the significant biological pathways are reported as fold enrichment. Clustering the pathways enriched by either CMV or ZIKV infection revealed apparent differences in the functional pathway enrichment patterns (Fig. 4). Forced clustering by functional pathway was used with hierarchical clustering within the groups implemented by rows. When hierarchical clustering is applied to columns, ZIKV up-and down-regulated gene pathways showed stronger similarity to each other than to CMV altered pathways (Fig. 4a). Examination of the cytokine/ chemokine specific pathways likewise indicated divergent expression profiles between viruses (Fig. 4b). Several cytokine-regulated pathways were activated in ZIKVinfected NPCs, while CMV-infected hNPCs showed limited representation of these pathways. Interleukin-5 (IL-5), granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor (GM-CSF), and interleukin-3 (IL-3) mediated signaling were comparably enriched but associated with the down regulated genes in CMV but with the up regulated genes in the CMV set. Additionally, the pathogen response pathways highly represented in the ZIKV birth defects are caused appears to be unrelated between viruses.

Immune and inflammatory responses in ZIKV-infected hNPCs
Given that the immune response gene enrichment seen in ZIKV-infected hNPCs differed from CMV infection, we further investigated the potential inflammatory pathways involved. Inspection of the biological pathways significantly enriched for ZIKV DEGs revealed a pattern of immunological term enrichment in genes up-regulated by the virus. Using search terms classifying immune related pathways our query returned 24 immune related pathways out of the 178 total in the ZIKV up-regulated genes (Fig. 5a). Of the 119 significantly enriched pathways of genes downregulated by ZIKV infection, none were related to immune function (Fig. 5a). Among the inflammatory pathways identified from the up-regulated genes, were Comprehensive gene set gene ontology analysis. Gene ontology analysis was performed on hNPC genes whose expression was significantly altered following infection with ZIKV for 56 h. Transcript enrichment significance was determined using the human protein coding genome as the reference background. a Regulation of nucleic acid metabolism was the only biological process sub-ontology enriched with ZIKV up-regulated genes. Down-regulated genes were enriched for pathways related to cell cycle regulation and general metabolism. All significant terms are presented. b Cellular component enrichment indicated down-regulated genes generally associated with chromosomal regions, the extracellular matrix, and centrosomes. Upregulated genes showed the most enrichment for the Golgi apparatus.
Both up-and down-regulated genes were significantly enriched in nuclear sites. Enrichment scores were sorted by the most significant terms, and the top 11 compartments are represented. (q < 0.05) ◂ altered genes are not significantly enriched in either the CMV up or down regulated gene sets (Fig. 4c). While both viruses can infect hNPCs and cause comparable birth defects, the apparent mechanism by which these the endosomal viral pathogen recognizing Toll-like receptor (TLR) 9 and TLR7/8 pathways which recognize CpG containing DNA and ssRNA, respectively [25]. TLR receptor signaling is primarily mediated through the adaptor protein myeloid differentiation primary response gene 88 (MyD88) in response to infection [26]. Other TLRs are located on the plasma membrane and recognize a wide variety of pathogen associated molecules [25] and were thus classified as pathogen response pathways. Additionally, several canonical inflammatory pathways were activated, including tumor necrosis factor (TNF) receptor pathways, interferon gamma (IFN-γ) signaling pathway, pathways involved in interleukin (IL)-1, IL-2, IL-3, IL-5, IL-6, IL-12, IL-23, C-X-C motif chemokine 12 (CXCL12)/CXCR4, pathway and GM-CSF mediated pathway (Fig. 5b). Cell and tissue type analysis of the whole ZIKV DEG gene set revealed representation of tissue types associated with immune and hematological function (Fig. 5c). Tissue and cell types exclusively associated with ZIKV up-regulated genes included the bone marrow, erythrocytes, and platelets. B-cells and dendritic cells were the only cell types exclusive to the down-regulated gene set. Both up-and down-regulated genes were enriched for monocytes, T-cells, leukocytes, and the thymus. The immune specific enrichment of the genes differentially expressed in ZIKV-infected hNPCs indicate involvement of both the innate and adaptive immune system. Dendritic cells are important antigen-presenting cells (APC) Fig. 3 Gene ontology functional network of biological process and immune system terms. All significantly altered genes greater than 0.5 foldchange were imported into Cytoscape and Gene Ontology clustering was performed with the ClueGO plugin. The human genome was used as the background with the GO biological process and immune system terms queried for enrichment. Terms were generated such that GO Term Fusion was implemented on pathways with a less than 0.01 q-value. Groupings with less than 3 connections were excluded from the final list of networks. Terms related to cytokine and chemokine production as well as general pathogen response formed networks independent of nucleic acid and macromolecule metabolic processes while T-and B-cells are primarily responsible for adaptive response. This enrichment points to a role for ZIKV inducing NPCs to take on a yet unclear immune-modulating phenotype.

Analysis of cytokine/chemokine associated intracellular signaling pathways
The two major immune cell pathways that control the production of inflammatory cytokines can be classified as being nuclear factor kappa-light-chain-enhancer of activated B cells (NF-κB) and signal transducer and activator of transcription (STAT) protein family dependent. Both NF-κB and STAT family-members are transcription factors that induce gene expression upon stimulation by wide variety of ligands. Figure 6 illustrates simplified versions of these pathways activated in ZIKV-infected NPCs. The pathogens (represented as pathogen-associated molecular patterns, PAMP) and TLR 7/8/9 pathways enriched in the ZIKV up-regulated genes (Fig. 4), induce gene expression primarily through nuclear translocation of NF-κB. Other NF-κB mediated pathways enriched in ZIKV up-regulated genes were C-X-C chemokine receptor type 4 (CXCR4), CD40, TNF, and IL-1 signaling (Fig. 4). STAT family induced genes can also result in inflammatory cytokine production upon activation of plasma membrane receptors. The enriched STAT family related signaling pathways were IFN-γ, IL-6, and IL-12 in the ZIKV up-regulated genes (Fig. 4).

Discussion
Our results show that collectively, ZIKV induced transcriptomic alterations are associated with established clinical pathologies. Following viral infection there is a reallocation of host nucleic acids and other metabolites towards viral specific replication processes [12], thus the enrichment of biological processes related to nucleic acid metabolism is an expected finding, as well as the enrichment of cell cycle regulation. The cell cycle perturbations of infected cells suggest the initiation of a G 1 /S checkpoint and impaired progression through G 1 [9]. A possible explanation for these cell cycle abnormalities could be inhibition of S-phase progression due to limited nucleic acid reserves as the virus reallocates them for its own replication. Down-regulation of critical epigenetic markers represents a possible driver for abnormal gene expression in infected cells. If NPCs in the developing human brain are diverted from normal development, it can result in conditions like microcephaly. Moreover, this raises questions about the possible long-term neurological effects in adult following ZIKV infection of adult neural progenitors. Although, the ZIKV associated clinical phenotypes were highly enriched for congenital CNS disorders, comparatively few genes were associated with adult CNS inflammation and demyelination diseases. This may be the due to the fact that the current study implemented the MR766 Ugandan isolate which has not been associated with an increased incidence of GBS and myelitis. As a result, future studies that employ more neoteric strains will likely observe increased representation of related genes. The significant enrichment of canonical immune system pathways in ZIKV-infected hNPCs proved to be another unexpected finding. Our study provides evidence at the transcriptional level that two major mediators of inflammation, NF-κB and the STAT family of proteins, regulate inflammatory response in hNPCs. NF-κB is one of the main transcriptional factors activated in response to pro-inflammatory cytokines, such as TNF-α and IL-1. It is also triggered by TLRs via pathogen-associated molecular patterns (PAMPs). The Janus Kinase (JAK)-Signal transducer and activator of transcription (STAT) pathway is also a major signaling pathway that regulates inflammation and mediates the responses of target cells to inflammatory cytokines. Activation of these pathways has a central role in inflammation through the regulation of genes encoding pro-inflammatory cytokines, chemokines, and inducible enzymes such as cyclooxygenase-2 (COX2) and inducible nitric oxide synthase (iNOS) [27]. Moreover, it has recently been reported that ZIKV-infected fetal brains display a number of inflammatory markers, including diffuse astrogliosis, and activations of macrophages and microglia [9]. It is conceivable that ZIKV-infected NPCs may exert immunomodulatory and inflammatory effects on CNS cells such as neurons as well as astrocytes in an autocrine, paracrine, and juxtacrine manner, thus amplifying brain inflammation. Interestingly, although congenital CMV infection can also result in microcephaly and general impaired brain development [24], the inflammatory signals were not observed in CMV-infected hNPCs. The significance of this is still under investigation. With the currently limited molecular data regarding transcriptomic alterations in infected host cells, large scale analysis is difficult. In spite of this, we present analysis of the currently available data in an effort to guide future studies. The RNA-seq was performed on only one infected cell type, hNPCs, thus we implemented stringent Benjamini Hochberg (BH) [28] false discovery rate (FDR) q-value cut-offs to limit false positives in enriched pathways. The use of the older MR766 isolate for the experiments likewise limits extrapolation of the results, even though it shares 88.9 % nucleotide and 96.5 % amino acid identity with the current strain [29]. Considering that reported pathogenicity has been increasing over time, the presented data likely represents a milder host response should any host transcript differences exist.

Conclusion
In conclusion, we report that ZIKV infection induces alterations to NPC immune response gene expression. While the primary infection typically occurs through the bite of an infected mosquito, the mechanism for entry into the restricted CNS is currently unclear. Presumably the specific physiology of the fetal blood brain barrier is permissible to ZIKV as it is to other viruses [24]. Regardless, it has been shown that the virus can infect NPCs with high efficiency leading to increased apoptosis [9]. In addition, the presented study is the first to report enrichment of numerous pro-inflammatory pathways in ZIKVinfected hNPCs, indicating that hNPCs are capable of activating pro-inflammatory immune system pathways following viral infections. This represents, in addition to direct activation of apoptotic pathways, a mechanism by which the virus could induce cell death via the propagation a cytotoxic pro-inflammatory environment in the CNS. Although it is possible that ZIKV can infect immune cells in a similar manner as the related Dengue virus [30][31][32][33], the ability of ZIKV to infect hNPCs may exacerbate CNS inflammation. Consequently, a better understanding of the cellular and molecular mechanisms regulation of the cross-talk between NPCs, CNS resident cells, and immune cells may be crucial for the development of effective strategies to treat ZIKV infection.

Gene sets and expression analysis
We analyzed the transcriptomic sequencing (RNA-seq) data (GEO: GSE78711) of ZIKV (MR766) infected human neural progenitor cells (hNPCs). Briefly, Tang et al. infected hNPCs derived from human induced pluripotent stem (iPS) cells with ZIKV. The infected hNPCs were incubated for 56 h, a time frame already proven sufficient for a greater than 60 % infection rate. RNA extracted from ZIKV-infected samples and mock infected samples was used for library generation and sequencing [9]. For comparison to the ZIKV-infected hNPCs, the expression data from iPCS derived NPCs infected with human CMV (Ad169) was implemented (GEO: GSE35295). The cells were infected with CMV, and the RNA was extracted 24 after infection for analysis on an Illumina HumanHT-12 V4.0 expression beadchip. Three biological replicates for control and infected cells were used, and a list of significantly altered genes were generated with a BH FDR q-value cut-off of < 0.05 [23].

Availability of data and materials
The datasets supporting the conclusions of this article are available in the gene expression omnibus (GEO) repository, http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/geo/.

Biological process and cellular compartment analysis
Using FunRich [34], up-and down-regulated genes with associated Log 2 FCs were analyzed for enrichment against the human annotated genome. Biological process, cellular compartment, and biological pathway significance was defined as a FDR q-value less than 0.05. All significant biological processes were presented. All 11 significant cellular compartments for the ZIKV up-regulated genes were presented, along with the top 11 most significant pathways enriched for ZIKV down-regulated genes.

Subsetting for immune specific biological pathway enrichment
The significant biological pathways associated with both ZIKV up-and down-regulated genes were filtered such that non-immune specific biological pathways were excluded. Significance was defined as a FDR q-value less than 0.05.

ZIKV genes associated with clinical phenotypes
Clinically relevant diseases associated with ZIKV DEGs were queried using the MalaCards [17] integrated database of human diseases. The absolute percentage of ZIKV DEGs present in the reference list derived from MalaCards was reported, as well as the total number of genes in the reference list.

Gene ontology network analysis
DEGs with an absolute fold change greater than 0.5 were imported to Cytoscape [20], where Gene Ontology clustering was performed using the ClueGO plugin [21]. The human genome was used as the background, and the GO biological process and GO immune system terms were queried for enrichment. Terms were generated such that GO Term Fusion was implemented for pathways with a less than 0.01 FDR q-value. Groups with less than three connections were excluded from the final network.

R packages
Heatmaps generated with the Bioconductor package ComplexHeatmap [35] within the R statistical computing environment [36].